Choosing Between VS1 and VS2 Diamond Clarity: Which Is Right for You?

October 11, 2024

When purchasing a diamond, understanding the nuances of clarity is essential for making an informed choice. Among the clarity grades, VS1 and VS2 diamonds frequently come up for discussion. This article will guide you through the differences between these grades, helping you decide which one suits your needs best.

What Does Clarity Mean?

Clarity refers to the presence of inclusions—internal flaws or external blemishes—that can affect a diamond's overall appearance. These imperfections are graded on a scale established by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), which assesses how noticeable these flaws are under 10x magnification.

The Clarity Scale: From Good to Poor

The GIA clarity scale includes:

Flawless (FL)
Internally Flawless (IF)
Very Slightly Included (VS1, VS2)
Slightly Included (SI1, SI2)
Included (I1, I2, I3)

Diamonds rated as VS1 or VS2 have very slight inclusions that are difficult to see without magnification, making them a popular choice for many buyers.

What Do the Numbers 1 and 2 Mean – VS1 and VS2?

The distinction between VS1 and VS2 lies in the degree of clarity. A VS1 diamond will have fewer inclusions than a VS2 diamond, and those inclusions will typically be less visible. While both grades are excellent, VS1 diamonds may appeal more to collectors due to their slightly superior clarity.

Can You Really See the Difference?

For most people, the difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds will not be noticeable without the aid of magnification. Both clarity grades produce stunning, sparkling diamonds that look beautiful in any setting. If you're looking for a diamond that appears flawless to the naked eye, either option is a strong contender.

Clarity Always Affects the Price

As with all the Four Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat weight), clarity significantly impacts a diamond's price. Generally, VS1 diamonds will be priced higher than VS2 diamonds due to their superior clarity. However, the price difference can vary based on additional factors like carat weight and market demand.

Price Comparison – VS1 and VS2

While the price gap can fluctuate, you can typically expect a VS1 diamond to cost around 10-20% more than a VS2 diamond. If you're on a budget but still want quality, a VS2 diamond offers excellent value without sacrificing beauty.

Why VS Clarity Grade is a Good Choice

Opting for a VS clarity grade strikes a balance between quality and affordability. Diamonds in this range possess minimal imperfections that won't detract from their brilliance, making them ideal for engagement rings or significant jewelry pieces.

Do VS Diamonds Have Investment Value?

Yes, diamonds graded as VS can be a good investment. Their quality makes them desirable to collectors, but other factors such as market conditions and overall demand will also influence their resale value.

You Should Buy VS1 Quality When:

You’re looking for an engagement ring: The higher clarity will make the diamond appear more brilliant and stunning, which is often desired for such a significant purchase.
You value investment potential: VS1 diamonds may retain or appreciate in value more than VS2 diamonds.
You want the best quality: If you appreciate finer details and want a piece that stands out, VS1 is the way to go.

You Should Buy VS2 Quality When:

You’re on a budget: VS2 diamonds offer great value while still looking beautiful.
You want a larger stone: You might be able to afford a larger carat weight if you choose a VS2 over a VS1.
You’re okay with minor inclusions: If you’re confident that minor imperfections won’t bother you, a VS2 can be an excellent choice.

Consider VS1 or VS2 Lab Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds offer the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds but often at a lower price point. When considering VS1 and VS2 clarity grades, lab-grown options can provide an ethical and affordable alternative without compromising on quality.

Don’t Forget That Inclusions Make Diamonds Unique

Every diamond has its own set of inclusions that contribute to its character and individuality. Choosing a VS1 or VS2 diamond means you're embracing these unique features while still enjoying a stunning and high-quality piece of jewelry.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice between VS1 and VS2 diamond clarity depends on your personal preferences, budget, and intended use. Both grades offer stunning beauty and will serve as timeless pieces in any jewelry collection. Whether you lean towards the refined allure of VS1 or the excellent value of VS2, either option will provide a diamond that you can cherish for years to come.

FAQs

1. What does VS mean in diamond clarity ratings?
VS stands for "Very Slightly Included." Diamonds in this category have minor inclusions that are difficult to detect without magnification, making them a popular choice for many buyers.

2. How do VS1 and VS2 diamonds differ?
The main difference lies in the number and visibility of inclusions. VS1 diamonds have fewer inclusions, which are typically less visible than those found in VS2 diamonds, making VS1 a slightly higher quality option.

3. Can I see the difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds without magnification?
For most people, the difference between the two grades is nearly imperceptible without magnification. Both grades will appear stunning and sparkly to the naked eye.

4. Why does clarity impact the price of diamonds?
Clarity is one of the Four Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat weight) that determine a diamond's quality and price. Generally, diamonds with higher clarity, like VS1, command a higher price due to their rarity and desirability.

5. What is the price difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds?
Typically, a VS1 diamond can cost about 10-20% more than a VS2 diamond, but this can vary based on other factors like carat weight and market demand.

6. When should I choose a VS1 diamond?
Consider choosing a VS1 diamond if you’re looking for an engagement ring, want the best quality, or are interested in investment potential. The higher clarity can enhance the diamond’s brilliance.

7. When is a VS2 diamond a better option?
A VS2 diamond may be better if you're on a budget, looking for a larger carat weight, or if you’re comfortable with minor inclusions that won’t affect the overall beauty of the stone.

8. Are lab-grown VS1 and VS2 diamonds a good option?
Yes, lab-grown diamonds provide the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds and are often more affordable. They can be an ethical choice without compromising quality.

9. What are inclusions, and how do they affect a diamond's appearance?
Inclusions are internal flaws in a diamond that can impact its light performance and overall appearance. However, minor inclusions in VS1 and VS2 diamonds are generally not noticeable and can even add character to the stone.

10. Do VS diamonds have good resale value?
Yes, VS diamonds can retain or appreciate in value due to their quality. However, resale value is influenced by other factors, such as market conditions and demand.

11. How should I choose between a VS1 and VS2 diamond?
Consider your budget, the diamond's intended use, and how much you value clarity. Both options offer stunning beauty, so your personal preference will play a significant role in your decision.

12. Can I get a VS1 or VS2 diamond in different shapes?
Absolutely! Both VS1 and VS2 diamonds are available in a variety of shapes, including round, princess, and emerald, among others. Choose a shape that appeals to you for your desired piece of jewelry.

13. What settings work best with VS1 and VS2 diamonds?
Both clarity grades work well with various settings. However, if you choose a VS2 diamond, you might consider a setting that enhances its brilliance, such as a halo design, to draw attention away from minor inclusions.

14. Should I prioritize clarity over other factors like cut and color?
While clarity is important, the overall beauty of a diamond also depends on cut and color. It's best to find a balance among the Four Cs to ensure you get the diamond that best meets your desires.

15. Can the unique inclusions in VS diamonds tell a story?
Yes! Each diamond has its own set of inclusions that contribute to its individuality. Embracing these unique characteristics can add a personal touch to your diamond choice.